| 1958 Season – SWC Champs | 1955 Season – SWC Champs | 1952 Season | |||||
| (7-1, ) Vince Gandolfi (6th year) | (9-0, 8-0) Vince Gandolfi (3rd year) | (0-9, ) Randall Motts (9th year) | |||||
| Brooklyn | 55 – 6 | Brooklyn (A) | 13 – 0 | Bay | 7 – 27 | ||
| Westlake | 24 – 16 | Bay (H) | 20 – 0 | Fairview | 6 – 31 | ||
| Bay | 14 – 16 | North Olmsted (H) | 20 – 13 | Clearview | 7 – 34 | ||
| Fairview | 31 – 12 | Medina (A) | 13 – 6 | Medina | 20 – 33 | ||
| Olmsted Falls | 15 – 0 | Westlake (A) | 45 – 7 | Wellington | 14 – 33 | ||
| North Olmsted | 14 – 6 | Olmsted Falls (H) | 39 – 0 | Oberlin | 28 – 40 | ||
| Oberlin | 8 – 0 | Oberlin (A) | 14 – 7 | Amherst | 7 – 25 | ||
| Medina | 51 – 12 | Fairview (A) | 19 – 13 | Wadsworth | 16 – 47 | ||
| 212 – 68 | Berea (H) | 40 – 19 | Norwalk | 14 – 20 | |||
| 223 – 65 | 119 – 290 | ||||||
| 1957 Season | 1954 Season | 1951 Season – SWC Champs | |||||
| (5-3, ) Vince Gandolfi (5th year) | (3-6, 2-5) Vince Gandolfi (2nd year) | (7-2, ) Randall Motts (8th year) | |||||
| Brooklyn | 39 – 0 | Brooklyn | 6 – 0 | SWC Champions | |||
| Fairview | 19 – 13 | Bay | 0 – 12 | Bay (H) | 0 – 7 | ||
| Olmsted Falls | 47 – 6 | North Olmsted | 6 – 20 | Fairview (A) | 16 – 0 | ||
| Oberlin | 12 – 19 | Medina | 19 – 20 | Clearview (H) | 22 – 7 | ||
| Westlake | 13 – 0 | Westlake | 14 – 13 | Medina (A) | 0 – 9 | ||
| Bay | 13 – 14 | Olmsted Falls | 7 – 19 | Wellington (H) | 35 – 13 | ||
| North Olmsted | 13 – 20 | Oberlin | 13 – 7 | Oberlin (A) | 26 – 18 | ||
| Medina | 40 – 13 | Fairview | 6 – 28 | Amherst (A) | 28 – 13 | ||
| 196 – 85 | Berea | 6 – 48 | Wadsworth (A) | 20 – 6 | |||
| 77 – 167 | John Hay (H) | 21 – 6 | |||||
| 168 – 79 | |||||||
| 1956 Season – SWC Champs | 1953 Season | 1950 Season | |||||
| (7-1, 6-1) Vince Gandolfi (4th year) | (4-4-1, ) Vince Gandolfi (1st year) | (7-2, ) Randall Motts (7th year) | |||||
| Bay | 21 – 21 | Bay (A) | 14 – 7 | ||||
| Brooklyn | 12 – 0 | North Olmsted | 12 – 32 | Clearview | 41 – 6 | ||
| Fairview | 19 – 13 | Fairview | 19 – 29 | Medina (H) | 13 – 20 | ||
| Olmsted Falls | 31 – 12 | Clearview | 19 – 6 | Oberlin (H) | 32 – 25 | ||
| Oberlin | 7 – 13 | Medina | 19 – 13 | Amherst | 44 – 0 | ||
| Westlake | 20 – 7 | Wellington | 19 – 12 | Berea | 13 – 6 | ||
| Bay | 21 – 0 | Oberlin | 13 – 33 | Wellington (A) | 13 – 12 | ||
| North Olmsted | 12 – 7 | Amherst | 7 – 33 | Fairview | 0-26 | ||
| Medina | 34 – 6 | Brooklyn | 22 – 0 | John Hay | 23 – 6 | ||
| 156 – 58 | 151 – 179 | 180-108 | |||||